‘The Substance’ (2024): A Review

Official The Substance Trailer

A Chilling Descent Into the Horror of Eternal Youth

The Substance is a body horror film that delves into the terrifying consequences of scientific obsession and the pursuit of eternal youth. Directed by Coralie Fargeat (Revenge), the film follows an aging movie star who becomes entangled in a mysterious, life-altering substance to remain youthful. As she experiments with this otherworldly material, her body begins to mutate into grotesque and horrifying ways, challenging her sense of identity and humanity.

The Substance

The Substance stands as a gripping entry into the body horror genre, offering a scathing commentary on social beauty standards. The plot follows Elisabeth Sparkle, a 50-year-old movie star who, after facing age-related rejection in the industry, turns to a mysterious substance that promises to restore her youth. As Elisabeth takes the substance, the transformation is not only physical but psychological, manifesting in the form of “Sue,” a younger, more perfect version of herself. This doppelgänger becomes a haunting embodiment of the beauty Elisabeth once possessed, and the film intensifies as Elisabeth’s obsession with Sue—and the substance—grows.

The narrative maintains a clear, coherent trajectory, with each scene carefully reinforcing the central theme of the dangers of beauty addiction and self-acceptance in the face of aging. The film’s 2.5-hour runtime flies by due to tight pacing, which never lets up. The plot is engrossing from start to finish, and the tension escalates with precision, leading to a climax that feels both inevitable and terrifying. The pacing is so well-crafted that what could have felt like a drawn-out affair is streamlined, leaving the audience fully invested in Elisabeth’s descent.

The tone is bleak, and the atmosphere is drenched in anxiety and despair. The film oscillates between sterile, almost clinical settings—representing the industry Elisabeth is being pushed out of—and grotesque, surreal sequences that mirror her internal decay. The body horror elements are visceral, heightening the dread of watching someone physically deteriorate in the pursuit of eternal beauty. Visually, the aesthetic choices are haunting. The cold, polished cinematography contrasts with the increasingly grotesque transformations Elisabeth undergoes, and the sparse dialogue allows the film’s mood to take over when words aren’t enough.

Performances

In The Substance, the performances elevate the film to an exceptional level; they blend emotional depth with the grotesque artistry of body horror. Moore delivers what can only be described as a career-renaissance performance, embodying the troubled protagonist, Elisabeth Sparkle, with a rare intensity. Her portrayal is nothing short of a masterclass in acting, particularly in a scene where she confronts her reflection in the mirror. This moment, where her internal struggle manifests into an outward display of rage and disgust, reveals layers of vulnerability and self-loathing that are both haunting and captivating. Moore’s ability to transition from the serene facade of a glamorous movie star to a tortured soul in silent despair underscores her remarkable range and commitment to the role.

Margaret Qualley shines as the younger version of Elisabeth, adding a compelling dynamic to the narrative. Her performance is both mesmerizing and understated, and it complements Moore’s portrayal. Qualley’s ability to portray the naivety and raw ambition of youth without overshadowing Moore’s established character shows her growing prowess as an actress. Each scene she appears in is charged with a palpable intensity, whether she’s navigating moments of triumph or grappling with chaos. Her presence on screen consistently reinforces her position as one of the most promising talents of her generation.

Dennis Quaid, as the Hollywood producer character, adds a layer of eerie charm to the film. His portrayal of a character who is both familiar and unsettling is executed with a deft touch, blending charisma with an underlying creepiness that resonates throughout the film. Quaid’s performance is a striking example of how subtlety can enhance the horror, making his character both captivating and unsettlingly real.

Overall, the ensemble cast in The Substance creates a richly textured cinematic experience, as each actor delivers performances that are both believable and deeply engaging. Their collective contributions not only drive the film’s narrative but also underscore the powerful themes of beauty, aging, and self-perception.

Article Continues Below

The Allure of The Substance

In The Substance, the cinematography and aesthetic are instrumental in crafting an atmosphere that is both mesmerizing and unsettling, amplifying the film’s body horror elements. The camera work is particularly noteworthy for its dynamic and often disorienting movements, which effectively mirror the protagonist’s psychological disintegration. The frequent use of tight close-ups and skewed angles creates a sense of claustrophobia and instability, drawing the audience into Elisabeth Sparkle’s disturbed world. This technique is especially powerful during scenes of transformation, where the camera lingers on the grotesque details of her metamorphosis, enhancing the visceral impact of the body horror.

The lighting in the film is equally striking, employing a stark contrast between the cold, clinical illumination of Elisabeth’s public persona and the shadowy, oppressive lighting that envelops her private turmoil. This duality not only emphasizes the disparity between her public and private selves but also contributes to the overall sense of dread that permeates the film. The use of shadows and dim lighting in key scenes creates an eerie atmosphere that heightens the horror, making the moments of grotesque transformation all the more shocking.

The sound mixing, too, plays a crucial role in the film’s aesthetic, with a score that oscillates between hauntingly beautiful and unnervingly discordant. The music often swells during moments of high tension, intensifying the emotional and psychological impact of the scenes. However, there are instances when the score becomes overwhelming, especially in more introspective moments. In these cases, a more restrained approach might have been a bit more plausible.

Production design and special effects work harmoniously with the cinematography, creating a world that is as unsettling as it is visually stunning. The attention to detail in the set design, combined with the effective use of practical effects, enhances the film’s eerie aesthetic. This synergy between visuals and effects ensures that the horror is not just seen but felt, drawing the audience deeper into the film’s hypnotic and disturbing narrative.

Overall, while The Substance excels in its visual and auditory presentation, the balance between score and visual storytelling could be restrained at times. Nevertheless, the film’s aesthetic achievements contribute significantly to its immersive and unsettling experience, establishing a distinctive and compelling entry in the body horror genre.

The End Result

The Substance masterfully merges body horror with biting social commentary, offering an unsettling but poignant reflection on the pressures of beauty and aging in Hollywood. What sets the film apart from its genre counterparts is its innovative exploration of these themes, delivered through Coralie Fargeat’s sharp direction and a relentless pacing that never feels bloated or indulgent. Moore’s transformative performance reignites her career, while Qualley continues to cement her place as a major talent in the industry. The film’s grotesque, yet invigorating, visuals perfectly match its psychological depth, making for a unique cinematic experience.

Whether viewers are seeking thrills, chills, or a thought-provoking narrative, The Substance has something for everyone. It offers more than just horror; it’s a reflection on the toll of a society obsessed with eternal youth. No one should be surprised if they leave the theater both mesmerized and disturbed because The Substance is a film that lingers.

You Might Also Be Interested In:

The Legacy of Beetlejuice

Sabrina Carpenter Will Have ‘A Nonsense Christmas’ At Netflix